First-of-their-kind indices from Calyx Global track carbon market quality

View now
How risky is the carbon credit market?

Current Calyx Risk Ratings Distribution

- Calyx Ratings

Calyx Global has to date assessed and rated 689 carbon projects across more than 25 different project types. Projects rated include removals and avoided emissions across nature-based to technology-based project types, from 8 different crediting standards and over 50 methodologies. When accounting for ratings of different carbon credit vintages, we have 828 GHG ratings.

We find variability of quality no matter what parameter is selected (type, standard, country, CORSIA eligibility and more). Sometimes the variability goes all the way from high risk (i.e. poor quality) to low risk, sometimes it is less broad, but a range (distribution) is nearly always there. While quality credits can be found in today’s market, there are few credit types that consistently deliver high quality.

The same remark is valid for the contribution to SDGs. Among the 350+ certified projects we've rated (e.g., CCB, SD VISta, Gold Standard for the Global Goals), we find differences in the degree of impact and level of evidence provided. This leads to Calyx SDG Ratings from +1 to +5, with +5 being the best rating that can be obtained in our framework.

Below are two charts that show a distribution of Calyx Ratings. These charts will be updated as our coverage grows.

689 projects rated in total.

GHG Risk Rating Distribution

SDG Impact Rating Distribution

About the author

Calyx Global

Keep up with carbon market trends

Get the weekly newsletter and stay in the loop.

Trusted By

Duke UniversityBanco SantanderCloverlyCargillMetaJP Morgan

Next Up